Experts Explain Why Lead Found In Fidget Spinners Is No Idle Threat


Print Article

That fidget spinner your kid canít put down? It turns out it may be putting children at risk for lead exposure.

Thatís according to a report out Thursday from a consumer advocacy group, the U.S. Public Interest Research Group Education Fund.

The organization tested the toys ó which represent the latest iteration of a long line of skill-based amusements that include yo-yos and spinning tops ó for lead.

At least two of about 12 models ó products called Fidget Wild Premium Spinner Brass and Fidget Wild Premium Spinner Metal ó were found to contain levels of lead that are unsafe for children, said Dev Gowda, a PIRG public health advocate who co-authored the report.

U.S. PIRG found the devices to have lead on their surface level and the layer immediately beneath.

Preventing lead exposure, especially for young children, is considered a public health imperative. It can impair brain development, especially in younger children, and have lifelong consequences.

Flint, Mich., for instance, made national headlines when lead was discovered in its public water system. The problem is also often associated with paint in old buildings.

Could a kidís toy really be the next culprit?

Bulls i Toy, which makes the two models, said in a letter to U.S. PIRG that the spinners are marketed toward people 14 and up, and therefore exempt from federal regulations about lead in toys. Target, which sells them, has no plans to stop. It also argued that the ď14 and upĒ distinction makes these general-use toys, not meant for kids.

The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, which comes up with safety standards for consumer products, also treats fidget spinners as ďgeneral use,Ē unless the company has specified they are for kids 12 and under. Childrenís toys, unlike general use ones, are held to tougher lead-level standards.

Consumer advocates are disputing that ďgeneral useĒ classification.

In the meantime, though, consumers need answers. How big a problem is this? Should parents be worried about kids who have fidget spinners? Should the toys be scratched off Christmas lists?

Kaiser Health News spoke with two lead experts: Jerome Paulson, an emeritus professor and pediatrician at George Washington University, and Ellen Silbergeld, environmental health professor at Johns Hopkins University. It turns out the answers are not necessarily clear or easy.

Q: There are countless brands of fidget spinners out there, and weíre just hearing about two of them. Is this a serious concern?

Paulson: Is this one batch? Is this 10 million fidget spinners? I donít know. Just touching them with kidsí hands is not going to be an issue. That doesnít go through the skin. But if this lead is on the surface of the fidget spinner, and therefore gets on the fingers of the kids, and the kids put the fingers in the mouth or put the toys in their mouth ó then, clearly, there is a pathway of exposure, and they shouldnít be in the hands of the kids.

Itís just impossible to know ó I certainly would not go running every kid whoís got a fidget spinner to the doctor until weíve got a better sense of how widespread this issue is.

Silbergeld: This is indeed a hazard that is of considerable concern. If this [lead] were buried inside, it would not rise to the level of concern. But given that it is, in fact, a layer ó a coating ó then, of course, itís right there.

My sense would be just to avoid fidget spinners altogether [until the CPSC tests them for lead]. I think that would be a prudent thing to do.

Q: Say I have a child who wants a fidget spinner. Would this put him or her at risk?

Paulson: There is no lead level that is safe, so we donít want kids exposed to lead at any level. Weíre more concerned about younger kids, because their brains are less finished, if you will. I understand these are ostensibly made for older kids Ö but thatís a distinction without a difference. The manufacturer and the sellers are fooling themselves if they think these wonít get into the hands of younger kids.

Lead is toxic for adults, too. If youíre one of the adults who chews on your pen, donít chew on your fidget spinner. You could be lead-poisoned, just like your kid could be.

Silbergeld: It would probably be important to talk about the age of the child and what is the experience of the child. Do they put things in their mouth or not?

Iím going to make a recommendation because I think it has a generally good basis for it, and I would say people should get their children tested for lead.

If you havenít had your child tested for lead at any point, this is a good time to start.

Q: What should I do if my child already has one of these? Throw it away?

Paulson: I donít think Iíd be very concerned. If parents want to check, there are these lead check kits that can be purchased at stores like Home Depot. They will reveal if there are high levels of lead on the surface of a toy. If itís a hazard, it should be taken back and handled as hazardous waste ó not just thrown in the garbage.

Silbergeld: If there is a determination that lead is present in this object in a way that it could result in exposure, then if parents have these things, they should throw them away.

If there is a determination that lead is present in this object in a way that it could result in exposure, then if parents have these things, they should throw them away. Ö This is quite wise and not hysterical, and is the sort of thing that makes the industry go crazy.

This is why we have these bans on toys. Ö This is not an unknown message.

Q: What about other toys? Is this a widespread problem?

Paulson: Every once in a while, this [issue of lead in toys] rears its ugly head again. Sometimes itís manufacturers not paying attention to regulations they need to. It sounds like theyíre paying attention to a regulation ó but when you think about it, itís not protecting the kid. You can say this is for kids 14 and older, not 6, and therefore doesnít need to comply. But the reality is, we know younger kids are going to get exposed to it.

Silbergeld: Your best bet is to buy toys made in the United States because, frankly Ö American toy manufacturers are totally understanding of and compliant with making products that do not contain lead.

We canít be totally confident in anything. But I think parents would be advised to get toys that are made in America.

KHNís coverage of childrenís health care issues is supported in part by a grant from The Heising-Simons Foundation.

Print Article

Read More National News

FACT CHECK: Out-of-context comments inflate stabbing statistics


November 17, 2017 at 5:00 am | FACT CHECK: Out of context comments inflate stabbing statistics Mass shootings are on the rise. This year has seen the Las Vegas massacre and two church shooting...


Read More

Roadwork in Boone County begins next week


November 17, 2017 at 11:00 am | Boone County drivers will have to deal with roadwork along sections of Interstate 70 and Route HH, according to a Missouri Department of Transportation news release. Roadwork on I-70 between the ...


Read More

Destination Moberly: A small town hopes to reinvent itself as a tourist spot


November 17, 2017 at 5:00 am | Diane Richardson of Main Street Moberly recognizes that to many outsiders, Moberly is just another small town they pass while traveling north or south on U.S. 63. But for a resident of the "Magic Cit...


Read More

Melissa Straw, March 8, 1970 ó Oct. 29, 2017


November 17, 2017 at 11:36 am | An idealistic spirit, a compassionate teacher, a dynamic presence, Melissa Marie Lock Straw, 47, died Oct. 29, 2017. Melissa was a loving mother, spouse, daughter, and sister, an engaging personality...


Read More

Contact Us

(208) 263-9534
PO Box 159
Sandpoint, ID 83864

©2017 Bonner County Daily Bee Terms of Use Privacy Policy