Federal court: Release or re-try man in Idaho murder case

AP

Print Article

BOISE, Idaho (AP) A federal court judge has ordered the state of Idaho to release or re-try a man convicted of murder in a shaken baby case more than two decades ago.

U.S. Magistrate Judge Ronald Bush ruled Wednesday that Idaho would have 120 days to either release Edward Stevens or give him a new trial, in part because prosecutors in Ada County earlier failed to disclose some favorable evidence to Stevens' defense attorney.

The judge also found that investigators failed to maintain the proper chain of custody for some of the evidence. Chain of custody rules are intended to ensure that evidence for criminal cases isn't tampered with.

The judge said the prosecutor should have discovered and disclosed that some of the key evidence used to support the shaken-baby theory came from tissue samples that may have been damaged by the embalming process.

Prosecutors said Stevens shook the child and hit the child's head against a bathtub, causing a fatal injury. But Stevens has maintained the child was injured during an accidental fall down stairs.

According to the court documents, Stevens was caring for his girlfriend's 11-month-old son on Dec. 27, 1996, when the child sustained a serious head injury and died the next day at a hospital.

Stevens told investigators that he was taking a nap and awoke to a thump, finding that the child had fallen down the stairs. He said he tried to rouse the child and administered CPR before calling 911 about five minutes later.

Prosecutors said they believed Stevens had been abusing the child for about six months and that he shook the child and slammed the baby's head against the bathtub. They said he then waited more than a half-hour before calling 911.

Experts and witnesses gave different opinions at Stevens' trial, some saying the child's body showed clear signs of abuse and shaking while others said earlier bruises were the kind that many newly mobile children get and that the injuries could have been caused by a fall.

The most crucial scientific evidence came from an eye doctor who testified about examining the child's eyes several months after his death.

That doctor stated that internal bleeding and a type of tissue damage known as "perimacular folds" was present in the eyes, indicating the child had been badly shaken.

But the prosecutors did not disclose that the eyes weren't removed from the remains during the autopsy, and instead were collected only after the child's remains had been embalmed.

At his trial, Stevens was found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. He appealed the case to the Idaho Court of Appeals, but lost prompting him to file the appeal in Idaho's U.S. District Court in 2014.

In his ruling, the U.S. District Court magistrate judge agreed that Stevens' defense attorneys could have used that information to show that the embalming process caused the damage to the eyes.

"It is beyond argument that the prosecutor was required to discover and disclose material impeachment evidence that C.W.'s (the child's) eyes may have been removed after the body was released to the funeral home and embalmed. That did not happen," Bush wrote.

Stevens doesn't have to prove that the evidence about the eyes would have convinced the jury to acquit him, only that there was a reasonable probability of a different result, the judge said.

The Idaho Attorney General's Office, which represented the state on the case, did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Print Article

Read More Business

IDL hiring event is Wednesday

February 18, 2018 at 5:00 am | Bonner County Daily Bee SANDPOINT Looking for a job or want to do something new? The Idaho Department of Labor is hosting a hiring event on Wednesday, Feb. 21. 17. The event, which will run from 11 a.m.-1 p.m., will be h...

Comments

Read More

Bill proposes mental health exception in felony battery law

AP

February 18, 2018 at 12:39 pm | BOISE, Idaho (AP) An Idaho lawmaker has proposed inserting a mental health exception in a 2014 felony battery law that protects health care workers. The Idaho Statesman reports Republican State...

Comments

Read More

'Black Panther' blows away box office with $192M weekend

AP

February 18, 2018 at 12:20 pm | NEW YORK (AP) A wave of feverish anticipation, fawning critical acclaim and groundbreaking cultural meaning pushed "Black Panther" to a record-setting $192 million debut in U.S. and Canada theaters...

Comments

Read More

Canine influenza spreads to East Idaho

AP

February 18, 2018 at 12:08 pm | POCATELLO, Idaho (AP) An Idaho animal hospital says it has been notified of a confirmed case of canine influenza in the eastern part of the state. The Idaho State Journal reports Alpine Animal ...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(208) 263-9534
PO Box 159
Sandpoint, ID 83864

©2018 Bonner County Daily Bee Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X