Spacer
Bonner County Daily Bee Logo

spacer Home News Sports Link Editorial Link Entertainment Link Special Sections Link Real Estate Archives Link Classifieds Link spacer
News Section Image Map
Spacer
spacer
The Latest
spacer

[Click here for more]

spacer
spacer
Archive Search
spacer
Enter keyword:


Maximum stories:  




Advanced Search
spacer
spacer


spacer
spacer spacer Email this story spacer Printer friendly version

Court reopens North Idaho snowmobiling trails
Posted: Thursday, Nov 09, 2006 - 09:35:19 am PST
By BRIAN WALKER
Hagadone News Network


POST FALLS -- Snowmobilers are applauding a court ruling on Tuesday that reopens popular North Idaho trails and backcountry riding areas.

"We're absolutely delighted," said Sandra Mitchell, public lands director for the Idaho State Snowmobile Association. "We think its a very fair decision. The judge listened to both proposals, saw maps and heard thorough discussion.

"This provides protection to the caribou and still allows for responsible snowmobiling in the area. People win, resources win and the caribou win. I don't know how much better you can get than that."

The order, issued by Chief U.S. District Court Judge Robert Whaley, modifies the court's prior snowmobiling restrictions and reopens popular area snowmobile trails and backcountry riding areas such as around Priest Lake just in time for winter.


The court's review came as part of an ongoing lawsuit filed by environmental groups challenging federal analysis of snowmobile impacts on an endangered population of woodland caribou.

That population, which has about 35 animals, is located primarily in Canada with individuals occasionally wandering southward into extreme North Idaho and northeast Washington.

The lawsuit was originally filed against the U.S. Forest Service and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and claimed the agencies failed to comply with the Endangered Species Act as it affects management of caribou.

In September, the court issued an order interpreting the Endangered Species Act which prohibited snowmobiling in the Idaho Panhandle National Forest Caribou Recovery Area. The order called for further proceedings to refine the scope of snowmobile restrictions, and directed the parties to work toward an agreement.

The snowmobile and environmental groups presented a joint proposal for relief, while the U.S. Forest Service proposal called for the opening of additional areas and trails for snowmobile access.

Tuesday's order said the joint proposal "appears to be the product of difficult negotiation" but found the Forest Service's proposal "best encompasses the goals and protections of the Endangered Species Act and is the most narrowly tailored in scope to achieve them."

"We are thrilled with this outcome, which provides for significant and unique riding opportunities for the upcoming winter season," said Craig Hill, a Priest Lake representative for some of the snowmobile groups. "While we entered our joint proposal in good faith and in the best interests of the snowmobiling public, we obviously prefer the Forest Service's proposal and are encouraged by the court's latest analysis."

The order reauthorizes snowmobile trail grooming on several routes, including the trail linking the east and west sides of Priest Lake, in the Pack River-Snow Creek area and riding along the Smith Creek-Cow Creek Trails near Bonners Ferry. The order further allows off-trail riding in the Roman Nose-McCormick Ridge area and in the popular Trapper Burn area adjacent to State of Idaho lands north of Priest Lake.

"It allows for both trail and mountain opportunities," Mitchell said.

The latest order will likely remain in place until the Idaho Panhandle National Forest develops a winter recreation plan, a process that could take a year or more.

"Our work is far from complete, and we will continue to argue for even greater snowmobiling opportunities in the planning process," said John Finney, a representative for Sandpoint area riders.

The snowmobile groups who are parties in the case are the Idaho State Snowmobile Association, Priest Lake Trails/Outdoor Recreation Association, Sandpoint Winter Riders, Priest Lake Chamber of Commerce, American Council of Snowmobile Associations and the Blue Ribbon Coalition.

Brian Hawthorne, public lands director for the Blue Ribbon Coalition, said more than 205,000 acres of the existing caribou recovery area are already closed to snowmobile access.

"Significant portions of these closures were adopted without public input or formal agency planning," he said earlier. "Hopefully our efforts in this will motivate the Forest Service to thoroughly and expeditiously generate a travel management decision that better balances caribou protection and reasonable public access."



NEW YORKER AGAIN. wrote on Nov 16, 2006 9:31 AM:

" Here’s where you guys have to THINK and PLAN. All I had to do was think about this for a few minutes after I first read this story. Hey Finney, you’re absolutely right, your work is far from complete. You say you will continue to argue for even greater snowmobile opportunities in the planning process. So what is your plan? How about placing a tax (oh I can hear all the locals screaming and jumping up and down even over the new york city street noise!) or attaching a cost to snowmobile riding in the pristine north Idaho? Raise some money at least while you let the land be scared and the air get polluted. Then, put that money back into the community. Hey, how about this "plan" - use that money you raise by implementing a cost to snowmobile riding, by selling user permits to ride snowmobiles (throw in ATVs for that matter). Is this in your plan? Here’s another idea for your "plan" – use the monies raised by selling snowmobile permits to form an exploratory committee that researches the migratory paths, times and habits of the Caribou to try to lessen the impact of damage to their territory and migration patterns. And, research the effect of the increased noise pollution the snow mobiles will cause, not only on the Caribou, but the effects on the bird and fowl life? And, have you researched the effects of the increase in air pollution those extra snowmobiles will cause, and that effect on the beautiful Tamaracks that only live in the purest of air? You’re not going to tell me I know more about and care more about your own backyard than you do? And, how will smaller animals be effected - that are in the food chain for the larger animals? What is the effect on the WHOLE ecosystem? Have you performed such research? What due diligence have you performed? You’re an attorney. You’re smart. Figure it out, but do Something. You take, you have to give back. I'll head you're committee. Be there soon. Note for the editors - I can only hope the editors don’t censor or edit my post (this one and the one right before it) just because they find it offensive. That’s the whole point of freedom of the press and this forum. We need to have a free exchange of ideas and debate. You’re not just going to post the opinions of locals are you? Now that would be prejudice and unfair. Just think how good you’ll look when you post this. "

NEW YORKER COMING TO TOWN. wrote on Nov 16, 2006 8:33 AM:

" Don’t you idahonians know how to protect the beautiful species, land and air that graces your presence? Did you know that Tamaracks grow only in the purest of air – in your own backyard – and you are ruining that. You are so vicious to out of towners coming in. Well I’ll tell you something, I am a New Yorker, a proud one, moving to the area and I am coming with a vengeance to protect the animals – Caribou, Grizzly, Wolves and the land that you are wiping out. Google Earth (know what that is?) shows how dramatic this is. Shame on you "locals." You continue to show your ignorance. You pounce on Californians and New Yorkers coming in to north Idaho. I read on these forums how Californians (who should toughen up and stop being so subservient) are, like, begging to be accepted. Screw that. I won’t beg for you to accept me. I don’t need or want your acceptance. I am moving in and going to change things in north Idaho for the better, for everyone. We’ll create job opportunities, because it’s apparent you cannot do anything but hunt, fish and kill. Respect, preservation and sustainability is what will be done. It requires sacrifice, dedication, long term planning, and deep thought. Get it? Apparently not, that’s why the Californians and New Yorkers are coming to north Idaho. To save it! Move over, take a seat, grow up --- and hang on! We'll educate you. "

karla duarte wrote on Nov 15, 2006 3:28 PM:

" When it comes to isolated populations you want to be as careful as possible to provide protection to allow recovery. In general there is little purpose to expanding urban noise and toys into remote areas. "

Terry Adams II wrote on Nov 13, 2006 8:28 AM:

" Why are we worried about the Caribou and their "extinction"???? there are tens of thousands of caribou in the north!!!! a few are south SOWHAT?!?!?! Someone's irresponsible mouth caused alot of trouble on this one. IMHO "

rpd wrote on Nov 10, 2006 5:38 AM:

" Once again the all mighty dollar rules. Don't worry about what will survive for the future generations....just get that tourist dollar and "don't tell me what to do". "

dennis rainey wrote on Nov 10, 2006 5:01 AM:

" it was nice to see the judge open the trails again as priest lake needs summer and winter projetcs to survive as there are very rare jobs that people can make a living with a family at priest lake as the usfs dont do logging any more i have lived there for 50 years and priest lake needs people to survie thank you Dennis Rainey "

POST YOUR OPINION
(optional)
   
* All comment posts will encounter a possible delay of up to 24 hours.

spacer spacer Email this story spacer Printer friendly version



spacer
Spacer
 

Bonner County Daily Bee
P.O. Box 159 / Sandpoint, Idaho 83864 / 208-263-9534

Bonner County Daily Bee Online is updated at 10am PST.