Court: Judge can decide whether to seal case

Print Article

BOISE (AP) — A judge has the discretion to seal a convicted sex offender’s case because his criminal record is hurting his finances, the Idaho Court of Appeals ruled Thursday.

But the appellate judges made clear in their ruling that they weren’t recommending a Bonner County judge actually seal the case — only deciding he has the power to do so, if he chooses.

The appeal was brought by a man calling himself John Doe, who was convicted in 1990 after pleading guilty to felony battery with intent to commit rape. In exchange for his plea, prosecutors dropped another felony sex crime charge. After he served four years in prison, Doe was released on parole.

A few years later, a judge found Doe wasn’t at risk of re-offending and said the man no longer would have to register as a sex offender.

Two years ago, Doe asked 1st District Court Judge Steven Verby to seal his criminal case, saying public access to the information was causing him economic harm. Doe contended he hoped to become a fire marshal in his community, but a background check disclosing his conviction might hurt his chances. He also said some of his current employer’s clients refused to let him work on their projects when they discovered he was a felon.

The state’s attorneys didn’t oppose Doe’s motion. But the lower court judge turned him down, saying a rule that allows judges to seal some cases to prevent financial harm wasn’t designed to protect criminals from their own histories. Verby said he therefore lacked the discretion to seal the case.

Simply put, the “consequences of having committed a felony may include financial or economic loss,” The judge said.

In his appeal, Doe argued the lower court was wrong in finding the economic harm rule didn’t apply to criminal defendants. The Idaho attorney general’s office opposed Doe in the appellate case, with Deputy Attorney General Russell Spencer contending the economic harm rule was designed to protect businesses and other parties with financial interests, not felons.

Doe was correct, the appellate judges found: The rules are broadly written and don’t specifically bar a criminal defendant from asking for their history to be sealed, and lower court judges do have the authority to decide such matters.

“That is not to suggest, however, that the motion must be granted here or in any similar case,” Judge Karen Lansing wrote for the majority. “On remand, the district court will have broad discretion to determine whether Doe’s claim of economic harm is so compelling as to outweigh the overarching public interest in disclosure.”

Chief Judge David Gratton agreed with the majority, but wrote that he believed the rule was designed to seal records to protect businesses, not criminals, from suffering economic harm.

Doe’s attorney, Michael Palmer of Coeur d’Alene, was out of the office and didn’t immediately return a phone call from The Associated Press.

Print Article

Read More News

SKåL Tap Room celebrates opening

July 19, 2017 at 5:00 am | Bonner County Daily Bee SANDPOINT — The Greater Sandpoint Chamber of Commerce welcomed SKåL Tap Room to the chamber with a ribbon-cutting ceremony on Thursday, June 22. Pronounced “skol,” and meaning cheers in Norweigan, ...

Comments

Read More

Sandpoint OKs financial policies

July 19, 2017 at 5:00 am | Bonner County Daily Bee SANDPOINT — Before she retires, city treasurer Shannon Syth wants to get a few things done first. One of those is to take financial practices already used by the city and turn them into official pol...

Comments

Read More

North Hughes fire forces trail closures

July 19, 2017 at 5:00 am | Bonner County Daily Bee NORDMAN — The Idaho Panhandle and Colville national forests issued temporary trail closures due to the North Fork Hughes Fire burning in the Salmo-Priest Wilderness, the U.S. Forest Service announced...

Comments

Read More

Athol resident becomes Oprah Insider

July 19, 2017 at 5:00 am | Coeur d'Alene Press COEUR d’ALENE — No longer do Oprah Winfrey fans need to peek under their seats to find a prize, because she started a program that conveniently ships gifts to them. O, the Oprah Magazine, selected a...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(208) 263-9534
PO Box 159
Sandpoint, ID 83864

©2017 Bonner County Daily Bee Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X