Priest Lake couple takes EPA challenge to high court

Print Article

SANDPOINT — A determined Bonner County couple who contends the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency is unfairly interfering with their right to develop a homesite at Priest Lake is taking their fight to the nation’s high court.

Counsel for Mike and Chantelle Sackett petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court last week to consider a series of lower court rulings concerning an EPA determination that federally regulated wetlands are present on their half-acre parcel in a Priest Lake subdivision.

The Sacketts sued EPA over the wetlands determination in U.S. District Court, but a federal judge dismissed the action in 2008 and entered a judgment in favor of EPA. The couple sought redress through the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals last year, but a three-judge panel ruled judicial review is not available.

A petition for the entire bench of the 9th Circuit to hear the request was also declined.

The Sacketts petitioned the high court to take their case and rule that they have the right to challenge EPA’s wetlands determination.

“The issue in this case is simple, but critically important to all property owners and everyone who values fair play and due process,” said Damien Schiff of the Pacific Legal Foundation, which is representing the Sacketts pro bono. “When bureaucrats try to impose their will on private property, shouldn’t the owners be permitted their day in court to challenge the government’s claim of control?”

The PLF, which bills itself as a watchdog group that litigates for property rights and a balanced approach to environmental regulations, is petitioning the higher court to a review lower court’s judgment for reversible error.

The group contends the 9th Circuit ruling foists an intolerable choice on landowners — spend hundreds of thousands of dollars applying for a permit of questionable need or risk an equally costly enforcement action with fines and penalties.

The PLF also argues the 9th Circuit’s ruling conflicts with an 11th Circuit ruling regarding review procedures for federal compliance orders.

The Sacketts have insisted on a hearing to test EPA’s jurisdiction of their property.

Print Article

Read More News

Women on trial visit scene of attack on North Korean scion

AP

October 24, 2017 at 12:17 am | SEPANG, Malaysia (AP) — The two women accused of killing the half brother of North Korean leader Kim Jong Un were taken back to the scene of the crime on Tuesday as their murder trial moved from the ...

Comments

Read More

ID Lottery

AP

October 23, 2017 at 3:35 pm | BOISE, Idaho (AP) _ These Idaho lotteries were drawn Monday: Lucky For Life 04-07-09-10-31, Lucky Ball: 15 (four, seven, nine, ten, thirty-one; Lucky Ball: fifteen) Mega Millions...

Comments

Read More

Winners of the 2017 Associated Press Northwest photo contest

AP

October 23, 2017 at 7:53 pm | SEATTLE (AP) — The winners of the 2017 Associated Press Northwest photo contest, announced Thursday at the annual meeting of the Pacific Northwest Newspaper Association. The Cowles trophy, awarde...

Comments

Read More

Stephen Hawking's Ph.D thesis goes online, website crashes

AP

October 23, 2017 at 11:05 am | LONDON (AP) — Cambridge University has put Stephen Hawking's doctoral thesis online, triggering such interest that it crashed the university's website. Completed in 1966 when Hawking was 24, "Pro...

Comments

Read More

Contact Us

(208) 263-9534
PO Box 159
Sandpoint, ID 83864

©2017 Bonner County Daily Bee Terms of Use Privacy Policy
X