Negligent boating law capsizes in Panhandle

Print Article

SANDPOINT — A ruling in the 1st Judicial District that Idaho’s negligent boating law is unconstitutionally vague is now final.

The state opted not to appeal the district court determination to the Idaho Supreme Court, court records show.

The ruling on the state’s negligent operation law stems from a case in which a Seattle man was charged for driving a powerboat into an anchored cabin cruiser at Priest Lake on July 4, 2012.

Nobody aboard the cabin cruiser was injured, although several people aboard the boat Todd Frederick Stauber was driving were.

Stauber was charged with negligent operation of a vessel, a misdemeanor.

Stauber’s defense counsel, Sandpoint attorney Bryce Powell, argued that the law was so vague that even lawful conduct could be construed as illegal. Powell cited a 1958 Idaho Supreme Court case which struck down the state’s former negligent operation of a motor vehicle statute because it contained no comprehensive standard of what constituted such misconduct.

Bonner County Magistrate Court Judge Debra Heise agreed that the law was unconstitutionally vague earlier this year and the case against Stauber was dismissed.

Heise noted in her ruling that the negligent driving statute was amended to enumerate prohibited conduct, but lawmakers inexplicably used the same faulty language in the negligent driving statute when they drafted the negligent operation of a vessel statute more than 30 years after the Idaho Supreme Court case.

The lower court ruling was appealed to the district court, but Judge Jeff Brudie upheld Heise’s ruling and subsequently issued a mandate requiring the magistrate court comply with the void-for-vagueness determination.

“This Court’s Opinion and Order on appeal has now become final,” Brudie wrote in a Nov. 21 remittitur.

The mandate is binding upon magistrate courts in the 1st Judicial District, which encompasses boating communities throughout the northern Panhandle. However, its applicability in other judicial districts in Idaho could remain subject to challenge absent a supreme court ruling.

State Sen. Shawn Keough, a Republican who represents Bonner and Boundary counties, said she is researching the issue and it could surface during the coming legislative session.

“I’m not aware of any other legislators that are looking at it, but, generally, we don’t have the opportunity to know what legislation might be introduced until we get to the capitol and start the session in January,” she said.

Keough said the lack of a supreme court ruling question does not necessarily mean lawmakers won’t perfect the language in the statute.

Print Article

Read More News

Police: Man pointed gun at neighbor

September 17, 2019 at 5:00 am | Coeur d'Alene Press A 58-year-old Athol man who is in jail on $25,000 bail after allegedly pointing a gun at a man following a property dispute was warned by a judge Monday to stay away from his neighbors. Kenneth L. S...


Read More

Driver who struck cyclist pleads guilty

September 17, 2019 at 5:00 am | Bonner County Daily Bee SANDPOINT — A Kootenai man is pleading guilty to inattentive driving in connection with a collision with a cyclist last month, court records show. Emil Lee Pedrini pleaded guilty to the misdemeanor ...


Read More

‘Eat In For Ethan’ set for Thursday

September 17, 2019 at 5:00 am | Bonner County Daily Bee SANDPOINT – Great sandwiches are teaming up with a great cause to benefit NAMI Far North on Thursday. Uptown Bagel Co. is once again hosting “Eat In For Ethan,” a fundraiser for the local chapter of...


Read More

Inspire Idaho nominated for national award

September 17, 2019 at 5:00 am | Bonner County Daily Bee SANDPOINT ­— The free app development initiative Inspire Idaho is a finalist in the 2019 Awards of Excellence, a national recognition from the University Economic Development Association. The honor c...


Read More

Contact Us

(208) 263-9534
PO Box 159
Sandpoint, ID 83864

©2019 Bonner County Daily Bee Terms of Use Privacy Policy